Store comparison · Updated 2026-07-15
Capitol Lighting vs Lighting New York
Two East Coast, family-scale, multi-brand lighting retailers with a century of combined history, and two of the most common answers to 'where should I actually order this fixture from?'
Capitol Lighting (1800lighting.com) has been family-run since 1924, with New Jersey and Florida showrooms and a white-glove streak: real humans on the phone, a 110% price-match guarantee, and recent expansion from acquiring Bellacor's brand assets.
Lighting New York is the Pennsylvania-based catalog powerhouse: enormous brand coverage, aggressive pricing, BBB-accredited service, and a pure-online focus that keeps overhead (and often prices) down.
Side by side
| Capitol Lighting | Lighting New York | |
|---|---|---|
| Country | United States | United States |
| Known for | Major fixture brands | Multi-brand catalog depth |
| Categories | Chandeliers, Pendant Lights, Ceiling Lights, Outdoor Lighting | Chandeliers, Pendant Lights, Wall Sconces, Ceiling Lights |
| Styles | Modern Lighting, Luxury Lighting, Farmhouse Lighting | Modern Lighting, Luxury Lighting, Vintage Lighting |
| Ships to | United States | United States |
Pricing, shipping, and returns change often. Confirm on each store's site before ordering.
Choose Capitol Lighting if…
- You value showroom backup and phone-first service
- Price-match guarantees matter to you
Choose Lighting New York if…
- You're hunting the lowest price on a specific branded fixture
- You're comfortable buying big-ticket lighting purely online
How this comparison works
Lighting Directory is independent: stores can't pay to be listed, ranked, or compared favorably. Comparisons are based on each store's verified catalog, positioning, and track record. See our disclosure for the full policy.
Frequently asked questions
- Are Capitol Lighting and Lighting New York the same company?
- No. Capitol Lighting is a family-run New Jersey/Florida retailer founded in 1924, while Lighting New York is a separate Pennsylvania-based online retailer. Both carry large multi-brand catalogs.