Store comparison · Updated 2026-07-15
Capitol Lighting vs Lighting New York
Two East Coast, family-scale, multi-brand lighting retailers with a century of combined history — and two of the most common answers to 'where should I actually order this fixture from?'
Capitol Lighting (1800lighting.com) has been family-run since 1924, with New Jersey and Florida showrooms and a white-glove streak: real humans on the phone, a 110% price-match guarantee, and recent expansion from acquiring Bellacor's brand assets.
Lighting New York is the Pennsylvania-based catalog powerhouse — enormous brand coverage, aggressive pricing, BBB-accredited service, and a pure-online focus that keeps overhead (and often prices) down.
Side by side
| Capitol Lighting | Lighting New York | |
|---|---|---|
| Country | United States | United States |
| Known for | Major fixture brands | Multi-brand catalog depth |
| Categories | Chandeliers, Pendant Lights, Ceiling Lights, Outdoor Lighting | Chandeliers, Pendant Lights, Wall Sconces, Ceiling Lights |
| Styles | Modern Lighting, Luxury Lighting, Farmhouse Lighting | Modern Lighting, Luxury Lighting, Vintage Lighting |
| Ships to | United States | United States |
Pricing, shipping, and returns change often — confirm on each store's site before ordering.
Choose Capitol Lighting if…
- You value showroom backup and phone-first service
- Price-match guarantees matter to you
Choose Lighting New York if…
- You're hunting the lowest price on a specific branded fixture
- You're comfortable buying big-ticket lighting purely online
How this comparison works
Lighting Directory is independent: stores can't pay to be listed, ranked, or compared favorably. Comparisons are based on each store's verified catalog, positioning, and track record — see our disclosure for the full policy.
Frequently asked questions
- Are Capitol Lighting and Lighting New York the same company?
- No — Capitol Lighting is a family-run New Jersey/Florida retailer founded in 1924, while Lighting New York is a separate Pennsylvania-based online retailer. Both carry large multi-brand catalogs.