Store comparison · Updated 2026-08-26
Lamps Plus vs Lighting New York
The two catalogs American shoppers land on most often when they already know which fixture they want. The split is simple: one sells you designs you cannot get elsewhere, the other competes hardest on the brands everybody stocks.
Lamps Plus is the largest US lighting specialty retailer and much of its range is its own: exclusive house brands, custom shade and finish programs, and a lamp selection deeper than most rivals bother with. It also runs physical showrooms across seven western states, which matters for anything you want to see lit before buying.
Lighting New York is the pure-online catalog play: heavy coverage of the national brands, a 150% price-match guarantee, free shipping over $49, and brand-level promotions that rotate hard. We track those tiers weekly on our deals page and they have turned over three checks running, so the discount on any given brand is genuinely short-lived.
Side by side
| Lamps Plus | Lighting New York | |
|---|---|---|
| Country | United States | United States |
| Known for | Wide selection in one place | Multi-brand catalog depth |
| Categories | Chandeliers, Pendant Lights, Ceiling Lights, Table Lamps | Chandeliers, Pendant Lights, Wall Sconces, Ceiling Lights |
| Styles | Modern Lighting, Farmhouse Lighting, Vintage Lighting | Modern Lighting, Luxury Lighting, Vintage Lighting |
| Ships to | United States | United States |
Pricing, shipping, and returns change often. Confirm on each store's site before ordering.
Choose Lamps Plus if…
- You want a fixture or shade nobody else sells
- You are lamp shopping rather than fixture shopping
- You can reach a showroom in AZ, CA, CO, NV, OR, TX or WA
Choose Lighting New York if…
- You have a specific branded fixture and want the best price on it
- A price-match guarantee is worth more to you than a showroom
How this comparison works
Lighting Directory is independent: stores can't pay to be listed, ranked, or compared favorably. Comparisons are based on each store's verified catalog, positioning, and track record. See our disclosure for the full policy.
Frequently asked questions
- Which is cheaper, Lamps Plus or Lighting New York?
- For a branded fixture both stock, Lighting New York's price-match guarantee and rotating brand promotions usually make it the sharper buy. Lamps Plus competes on its own exclusive designs instead, where there is no identical product to price-match against.
- Does Lamps Plus have physical stores?
- Yes, showrooms across Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, Oregon, Texas and Washington. Lighting New York is online only, so everything is judged from photographs and specifications.